I understand your point, and your predicament. We should pull @peter, @headrollsoff or @Jess into the discussion for some expert opinions on the subject. Their experience may lend some helpful perspective. I think it comes down to what is both manageable and possible for the database, I am generally of the opinion that one rates a game based on their preferred experience of a game. Using your Borderlands example, I would likely only rate the better of the two versions when assigning a rating to the game, providing I own it on multiple platforms. That’s what I tend to do. I think some people may even mention disparities between versions like that in their game reviews, if they have played the game on multiple platforms. I am not sure what the best solution is, but I’d love to hear from others on the subject.
1 Like