Alright, so here’s my idea!
We have to make this as group friendly as possible, obviously. Which brings up the issue of different people having different games and different consoles or a PC. Chances are, with it being so few of us at the moment, whatever game picked, probably wouldn’t get played by anyone.
I see this as an opportunity for 2 things, conquering some backlog, and growing the forum. So my suggestion is this, everyone in the ‘club’ can nominate a couple games each month (the number of games we can nominate depends on group size). For now there’s just a few of us, so I’d say 2-3 games would be good, once we get a bit larger, we’ll drop it down to just 1.
The chosen games would be compiled into a list of that month’s backlog games to play. It may turn out that the only games you’re interesting in play are your nominations, and that’s fine. When you complete a game, you create a thread in the forums for it for discussion (as long as you’re the first one to finish it, otherwise use the thread another backlog club member created).
You don’t have to finish a game either. We’ve all played a game we ended up disliking and not wanting anything else to do with. This club isn’t meant to make anyone play a game they don’t like.
Anyway, all of the chosen games will have a special badge related to them for you to receive upon completion. For example, lets say you finished Dragon Age 3, the badge could be ‘Inquisitor’. I’ve no problem making a special image for each of the badges. I think the badges should remain open for earning later as well, just in case someone can’t get to a game on the month it was chosen.
Obviously this relies on a bit of trust, someone COULD claim to have played a game and never even touched it. Though to receive your badge, you do have to participate in the discussion of it. Meaning if you’re the first, you create the thread and share your thoughts, or add your thoughts to an existing thread.