I realized I never shared my thoughts on the Star Wars sequel trilogy. It was my first time watching them, and my general feeling for them is… (drumroll) …not great?
The Force Awakens – Pretty bad. Felt too much like a rehash of stuff I’d already seen before. Didn’t do enough to make me care about the new characters.
The Last Jedi – Pretty bad. For each really interesting idea it explored, it had two rather boring subplots. And then by the end, it didn’t feel like it truly committed to breaking away from tradition. Of the three, this is the one I wanted to like the most, but it mostly fell flat for me.
Rise of the Skywalkers – Pretty bad. A lot of spectacle to be had, but in the end it felt like all flash and no substance. And again, it fell into the familiar beats of past films.
I did think there were some cool lightsaber battles and whatnot in these films. But the story was a really jumbled-up mess, and every time I thought they were going to go in an interesting new direction for the leads (namely Rey and Ren), the rug always got pulled out from under me.
It’s been interesting to look at reviews for these films now that I’ve seen them! It really seems the general consensus is something like “great fun” for 7, “extremely divisive (love or hate)” for 8, and “the worst film ever” for 9. But I ended up finding them all about the same level of quality. I would say the lows of these sequels are not as bad as the lows of the prequels, but I’ve interestingly ended up feeling the prequels are overall more memorable – they were generally a swing and a miss, but at least they were doing something different.
If I were to pick one main fault for the sequels, it’s that they always had one foot stuck in the original trilogy. The new characters were always in the shadow of the old ones. Which is too bad! As I thought the acting overall for these new characters was perfectly fine.
At some point I’ll give Solo and Rogue One a watch. I’ve heard mixed reactions to both of those, but I’m down for more low-key self-contained adventures within the Star Wars universe.